Categories: Electrician at home, Automata and RCD
Number of views: 151,355
Comments on the article: 17

How to choose a differential machine

 

How to choose a differential machineBefore talking about the choice of a differential automaton, it should be explained how this issue has earned such popularity. Why are differential automata good? Of course, by the fact that the difavtomat is a device that provides the line not only protection against overload currents and overcurrents of short circuit, but also protection against leakage currents, that is, protection against electric shock from a person.

In other words, a single device provides the full range of necessary protections. This is very convenient because it saves space in the distribution board and simplifies installation. In some cases, money savings are also achieved, but this is relative, since a high-quality differential machine can be more expensive than a single machine residual current device (RCD).

So, what is good for difavtomat, clearly. It remains to decide how to choose it.


1. Phase

Like any other protection device, the difavtomat should be selected based on the phase of the network. Three-phase differs have three poles for connecting the phases and one pole for the neutral working conductor. For obvious reasons, the three-phase differential differs in large dimensions and occupies six to seven modules. Single-phase diffs can occupy two to four modules, depending on the version. However, in any case, the difavtomat will take up much less space than a conventional machine and RCD combined.


2. Rated voltage

Although in the general case it can be difficult to miss: three phases - 380 volts, and one phase - 220 volts. But still, there are rare unpleasant exceptions, and you should pay attention to the nominal voltage of the device.



3. The characteristics of the releases and the rating of the machine

Since the differential is too circuit breaker, then of course he also has characterizationdisplayed by the letter of the Latin alphabet in front of a number representing the nominal value of the current load. As for household networks, here traditionally the most popular are the automatic machines of characteristic C.

For example, for a socket network, a difavtomat of characteristic C16 (less often C25) is suitable. For lighting networks, C6 or C10 machines are used. More rarely, automatic machines of characteristic B are used. Automatic C50, C63, C80 and C100 machines are often used as input common house or apartment switches.

Differential automatic machines ABB

4. Leakage current rating

This is a characteristic of the residual current circuit breaker included in the difavtomat. Nominal leakage current indicated by the symbol "delta" and a number indicating the actual leakage current with the letters mA (milliamps). To protect the outlet and lighting networks, diffuses with a rating of 10-30 mA are usually used. Most often, group networks are protected by 30 mA devices, and single sockets by 10 mA. The introductory difiltomat can have a built-in RCD of 100-300 mA.


5. Type or class of embedded RCD

It has long been known that there are RCDs of type AC that respond only to a sinusoidal (alternating) leakage current, and there are RCDs of type A that respond to DC leakage in devices with electronic converters. All this applies to RCDs built into difavtomaty. Thus, for lines supplying computers, televisions, and even washing machines, it is advisable to use difavtomats with built-in RCDs of type A, since the type of speaker can simply turn out to be ineffective.


6. The presence / absence of protection against a break in the neutral conductor

This is a very curious moment. The fact is that for the operation of the built-in RCD, it is necessary to power the differential protection unit. This power is taken from the input of the device. That is, in order for the differential protection of the difavtomat to work, it is necessary that there is voltage in the network.

This means that both zero and phase working conductors must be in order.Moreover, if there is no “phase" - then God is with him, because the leakage current is nowhere to come from. Another thing is if zero is cut off. Then the remaining "phase" can cause a leak, and the built-in RCD will no longer work due to lack of power.

To prevent such a phenomenon, some difavtomats incorporate a block of protection against the breakage of the neutral conductor, which in essence is a voltage relay, whose contacts operate to open.

If there is no such unit in the differential, then there are all reasons to independently install on the input of the voltage relay to control the situation.

Differential circuit breaker

7. Difavtomat manufacturer

No matter how strong the desire to save, it is better to refrain from acquiring diphs of dubious origin. There are well-known cases of the appearance of cheap automatic machines on the market, which upon closer examination were not even automatic machines: they did not have any releases, except for mechanical manual ones.

It is completely logical that there is the possibility of acquiring a difavtomat of a similar design. But a differential is an apparatus whose functions are often not duplicated in any way. That is, the safety of the power grid as a whole remains on the conscience of the dif. And he simply must be of high quality. We will not give specific instructions on brands and brands, but it is better to purchase devices in trusted stores and not rush at excessively low prices.


8. General instructions

Each difavtomat has a “test” button in its composition, allowing you to check its performance by creating an intentional leakage of current. After installing the device, it will always be worthwhile to carry out a small check using this button.

In addition, it should be remembered that not every line must be equipped with differential protection. Most often, diflavomats are placed on cable lines of sockets, as well as on the common input for fire fighting purposes. The lighting and power lines of an electric range are often not equipped with differential protection.

Not that it could be taken as a guide not to put difavtomats on these lines. But you can take into account, for example, in the absence of sufficient space in the switchboard, use simple circuit breakers for the lighting network and the cable line of the electric stove.

Difavtomats, as well as RCDs, are recommended for installation in networks that include a protective neutral PE conductor. This is an PUE requirement. In the absence of protective grounding, the protection itself from leakage currents may not be effective enough and not save a person from electric shock.

Difavtomats and RCDs are important not only to choose correctly, but also to connect without errors. How to do this correctly is described in this article:Schemes for connecting RCDs and differential machines. Follow the publications on our website!

See also at i.electricianexp.com:

  • Automata, difavtomats and ouzo, problems of choice
  • Protection against leakage currents: RCD and difavtomat
  • Main characteristics of RCD and difavtomatov
  • How is difavtomat arranged and what is it used for
  • What to do if an RCD or a difavtomat works when you connect a washing ...

  •  
     
    Comments:

    # 1 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    The article is really good, but I had a question on item number 5. But what about the current opinion among electricians that it is not worth putting RCDs and difavtomats on sockets to which the computer will be connected. And, that this slightly tricky device (meaning a computer) can cause a false alarm of protective devices and the second point is that in case of a thunderstorm, these protective devices can spontaneously work? And in paragraph number 5 you mention computer sockets.

     
    Comments:

    # 2 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Andrey, everything is simple. I do not share this "prevailing opinion." Correctly choose an RCD (difavtomat) - and there will be no problems.

     
    Comments:

    # 3 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    .... AND THERE IS WITH THE LAST BOTTOM (ABOUT THE EARTHING) I would argue that the RCD works when there is a difference in the flowing currents, i.e.EVEN WHEN TOUCH ON ONE OF THE CONDUCTORS, the RCD must MOVE, when the RCD is installed, we CONNECT the PHASE and ZERO WITHOUT "PE" .... THERE IS A CASE, IN THE SOCKET WITHOUT A CIRCUIT OF RESPONSE TO THE CIRCUIT. BY USING A FILE WITHOUT A HANDLE, AN ATTEMPT TO ATTEMPT THE SHARPENING OF THE NEEDLING STICK, ... GLORY UZO! ... however, I managed to feel the half-period of the alternating current (in 0.2 seconds)

     
    Comments:

    # 4 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Well, not a half period, but 10 periods so, judging by the time)

    That is the question. If at the three-phase input into the multi-apartment building a neutral wire burns out, and all apartments (and these are refrigerators, at least and all kinds of power supplies) will be connected to each other by 380, i.e. like motor windings with a star, but with unequal loads on different phases, which means unequal voltage on consumer groups (volt 260 on one group, 180 on the other 180, 280 on the third, i.e. conditional zero is shifted). So will the difavtomat work in this case, or what protection will work from this?

     
    Comments:

    # 5 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Why would he work, then? There are other devices to protect against overvoltage.

     
    Comments:

    # 6 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    The EKF difavtomat will work at 270V, it has built-in protection against voltage increase.

     
    Comments:

    # 7 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Well, how do you understand that there is protection against a zero break or not. "A" defense or "ace" - we are waiting for a more detailed article with examples!

     
    Comments:

    # 8 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Evgeny,
    That is the question. If at the three-phase input into the multi-apartment building a neutral wire burns out, and all apartments (and these are refrigerators, at least and all kinds of power supplies) will be connected to each other by 380, i.e. like motor windings with a star, but with unequal loads on different phases, which means unequal voltage on consumer groups (volt 260 on one group, 180 on the other 180, 280 on the third, i.e. conditional zero is shifted). So will the difavtomat work in this case, or what protection will work from this?

    There will be no interfacial voltage, this is absurd, the difavtomat will not work if it is not equipped, and there are also such models, by monitoring the breakdown of the working zero, in this situation, the danger of electric shock is great, because in contact with the "phase" casing of the non-grounded washing machine and the pipe, then you know.

     
    Comments:

    # 9 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    I remember the 90s. I had a video deuce-TV-recorder. So the tape recorder flew out and the TV did not work either.

    Conclusion - all that is completed in one case is ....

    Therefore, it is necessary to put everything separately in such a sequence - a voltage monitoring relay, which has its own 220 V supply. And if "0" is missing, the switching contact opens and, accordingly, all consumers are de-energized, then an RCD is installed, and then only current protection.

     
    Comments:

    # 10 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    The article is interesting and useful. But there are comments.
    1) machines with a leakage current of 10 mA are used in hazardous areas - bathrooms, baths, saunas, laundries. To protect computer technology, automata with characteristic B are used.
    2) differential. I didn’t meet machines with break protection of the neutral conductor. Maybe somewhere there.
    3) Dif. machines and RCDs First of all, they are placed for the safety of people from electric shock. Fire function (disgusting wiring and fire due to its fault directly result from current leakage!)
    4) << Difavtomaty, as well as RCDs, are recommended for installation in networks that include a protective neutral conductor PE. This is a PUE requirement >> So a requirement or recommendation? I have not seen anything like this in the PUE ...
    4) both to the RCD and to the differential. only phase and neutral are connected to the machine. And the presence or absence of a PE conductor does not affect their operation. But I agree that the presence of a PE conductor increases the degree of protection for people.

     
    Comments:

    # 11 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Nikolay,
    according to the second paragraph, protection against a break in the neutral conductor.there are also more expensive, read more here .... the link does not allow to insert. Look for articles on how to distinguish electromechanical RCD from electronic. Thanks for the articles, I read regularly.

     
    Comments:

    # 12 wrote: Sergei | [quote]

     
     

    Differential automatic machines are more correctly called "Automatic residual current circuit breakers" (AVDT).

     
    Comments:

    # 13 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Very high quality article. 10+
    If someone needs more, then take specialized literature and read. For the average man more than. Yes, and for a home electrician, excellent.

    According to the comments.

    Dump in a bunch, too lazy to quote.
    1) Any differential machine (AVDT in our opinion) from a good manufacturer (ABB, Legrand) has the property of protection against increased voltage and is triggered by a power surge to 264-272 In which it is more than enough to protect against a "break" of zero, and simply jumps voltage.
    2) If you have funds, you can put diffs everywhere, it won’t be worse. The current is right to choose which one for which consumer. If the differential works on the computer, either it is not selected according to the parameters, or it does its job perfectly. The trick of the computer is that this contraption works like no other electric device (at home), and air is circulated for cooling in it. Due to increased circulation, it simply accumulates a sea of ​​dust, which is an electrical conductor. This is where the leak occurs. If the case is earthed, then on PE, if not earthed, then, for example, on a person, I think that many were beaten as static when touching the computer, and some felt the phase, but since there was nowhere to flow (the floor covering usually has sufficient dielectric property), and dust could burn out during the flow of current, then that was all. So keep your equipment clean and there will be no “false” (in your opinion) trips.
    3) Specially for # 10
    1) simple machines do not have the ability to respond to leaks
    2) eat
    3) Of course, ouzo and diffs are set for safety. but the wiring is not on leaks, but due to a short circuit (this is very rarely a leak) (well, very direct, very rarely) or, what is actually most often, due to conductor overload. And for so that the wiring does not burn, a simple machine with the correct matched fuse or fuse (a very good thing, especially if it’s in the outlet ... yes, yes there are such outlets).
    4) Even as it affects. If you have PE, then the likelihood that the leak will go to the case and the grounding conductor is close to 100% and as a result of the RCD will work without waiting for a human touch. In my opinion this is much better than for example a small child is suitable, he will be shocked and he will inflict falling yourself an injury.

     
    Comments:

    # 14 wrote: MaksimovM | [quote]

     
     

    A current of 100 mA and higher is fatal to humans. Therefore, if there is a 100 mA difavtomat at the input, then in the event of a difavtomat failure in one of the outgoing wiring lines, a person will not be reliably protected from electric shock. Therefore, I think that it would be more correct to choose a differential automaton with a lower threshold for operation. If the technical condition of the wiring allows, it is possible to install an input redundant protective device with a threshold of 30 mA.

     
    Comments:

    # 15 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    Tell me, be kind, everything seems to be clear, but since I'm not an electrician, I can’t calculate which differential I need, the input to the whole apartment.

     
    Comments:

    # 16 wrote: Vyacheslav | [quote]

     
     

    Professional citizens please tell me, and because of what can a differential automatic machine fail? In my bathroom for 12 years already the second diflavomat machine breaks. Maybe the truth is because this is not a very high-quality IEK C25 on which there is a rather large load (boiler + washer), but when they were commissioned at home, all of them stood and the other three worked fine (pah-pah-pah) work.The first time without going into it I changed it to almost the same, the only thing was that the leakage current took 30mA, and not recommended for 10mA baths, as it was, because the washer caused “false” responses. And now I think, maybe it’s something else to put in place of IEK, but so that it is slightly more expensive (up to 20 bucks).

     
    Comments:

    # 17 wrote: Sergei | [quote]

     
     

    #16

    Is he standing in the bathroom itself? What microclimate is there?

    Why is IEK substandard? Is the load adequate in general (it is not clear by the names of consumers)?

    Why false? Maybe not false?