Categories: Featured Articles » Electrician at home
Number of views: 42819
Comments on the article: 5

How to choose circuit breakers and RCDs?

 

How to choose circuit breakers and RCDs?When repairing or replacing wiring, the question necessarily arises of choosing protection devices - circuit breakers, RCD and difavtomatov.


Circuit breakers protect the line from overload currents and short circuit currents. For example, you have turned on an overly powerful heater or electric oven in a conventional outlet, the current in the line exceeds the value that is permissible for it, the wire begins to heat up and, in order to prevent overheating and melting of the insulation, the circuit breaker trips and disconnects this line after some time.

In the event of a short circuit in the line, the circuit breaker trips almost instantly, disconnecting the protected circuit.


Residual current devices (RCD) They are used to protect a person from electric shock when touching live parts and to prevent dangerous leakage of current if the insulation of the wiring or household appliances is damaged, which can cause a fire.

For example, as a result of damage to the insulation, a potential dangerous to humans may appear on the body of the electric stove. Also, a person may accidentally touch a bare phase wire, which is energized, or a child, playing, shoves something metallic in the socket. Also, as a result of natural aging or damage to the insulation of wires, weakening of contact joints, current leaks occur, which lead to sparking and can cause a fire. To protect against such situations, RCDs are also used.

How to choose circuit breakers and RCDs?In order for the protection to be effective, it is necessary to correctly calculate and choose the protection devices. The reliability and safety of operation of the wiring and the electrical appliances connected to it depend on this.

I believe that in order to correctly calculate and select protection devices, it is necessary to fulfill three main factors:

- know the purpose, design of the protection device and understand the principle of operation of all its components;

- it is necessary to clearly understand the basic parameters and characteristics;

- know the standards and methods of choice.

Not knowing the purpose and design, not understanding the principle of action, proceeding to the choice does not make sense.

The main characteristic of the circuit breaker is the rated current, and the RCD is the rated breaking differential current (leakage current setting). In addition to the main characteristics, each of the protection devices has several more important parameters that must be considered when choosing them.


It is necessary to take into account the age and material of the wiring (it is new or old decrepit, copper or aluminum), the quality and condition of the connections. Wiring can be in a new house, or maybe in an old one, a house can be located close to a transformer substation - these factors affect the characteristics of protection devices, and this should be taken into account when choosing them.

The temperature of the room in which the electrical panel is installed, the number of installed devices nearby, the line load, all these parameters must also be taken into account. How do these factors affect circuit breaker operation? read this article.

Circuit breakers and RCDs are usually connected according to a multi-stage (tree-like) circuit.

For example, a typical electric circuit of a private house: an opening machine at the entrance to the house, a general machine in the electrical panel of the first floor, a general machine in the electric panel of the second floor. On each floor, the network is divided into separate groups: sockets, lighting, separately connected devices (electric stove, boiler, washing machine, air conditioners, etc.)

If an accident occurs in any of the groups, only the protection device of this group should be triggered, be it a circuit breaker or a residual current device. Those. selectivity must be fulfilled, it is ensured by the correct combination of parameters of higher and lower devices.

So non-observance of selectivity for RCD will lead to the fact that in most cases a higher RCD will work, or both at once. And this makes it difficult to find and eliminate the malfunction that led to the operation of the RCD.

Different types of electrical appliances in the event of a malfunction can create different types of leakage currents. For the most effective protection of people from electric shock, it is necessary to choose an RCD of the appropriate type.

Also, various types of RCDs behave differently under emergency power conditions. So with neutral wire break some types RCDs turn out to be inoperative, and this is a fairly common occurrence in our homes.

Well, without knowledge of the PUE and other regulatory documents, it is simply impossible to proceed to the selection and calculation of protection devices.

After the RCD has been selected, it is very important to connect it correctly in the electrical panel: RCD connection diagrams

The multimedia video course "Circuit Breakers and RCDs - Selection Strategy" offers a comprehensive solution for the design, operating principle, main parameters, methods for choosing circuit breakers, RCDs, differential machines, you will find answers to many questions in it, you can freely start repairing or replacing wiring in his apartment.


P.S. Links to the video course removed due to loss of relevance.


See also on this topic:Selection of circuit breakers for an apartment, house, garage

See also at bgv.electricianexp.com:

  • Automata, difavtomats and ouzo, problems of choice
  • About electrical protection devices for "dummies": automatic switches ...
  • Is it worth replacing a circuit breaker if it "knocks out"?
  • How to choose a circuit breaker for home, apartment
  • How to choose the right electrical panel for an apartment and a house

  •  
     
    Comments:

    # 1 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    The article is called "How to choose circuit breakers and RCDs?", But nothing is written about the choice ... How to choose something?

     
    Comments:

    # 2 wrote: MaksimovM | [quote]

     
     

    VladimirI’ll try to answer your question. I’ll supplement the article a bit. The circuit breaker is used to protect the electrical wiring of the apartment and electrical appliances that are connected to the network from damage due to emergency conditions such as overload or short circuit. The circuit breaker must be selected so that it provides reliable protection for all elements of the wiring and electrical appliances. The main parameter that guides when choosing a circuit breaker is the rated current of the wiring elements (cable or wire, socket), as well as the actual load current on one or another part of the wiring. If your outlet is designed for 16 A, and the wiring line (cable) is 27 A, you must choose a circuit breaker that will protect both the cable and the outlet. In this case, select the 16 A.

    A circuit breaker of any rating in the event of a short circuit in the wiring diagram will turn off in any case. As for exceeding the rated current, that is, overload on the wiring lines, in this case it is not always possible to provide reliable protection for all structural elements of the wiring. For example, you have laid a line from the distribution panel to the distribution box of one of the rooms of the apartment, and from this line there are several lines supplying the sockets of this room.In this case, the line to the junction box has a rated current of 40 A; the lines that go from the junction box to the sockets are 25 A, and the plug sockets installed in this room have a rated current of 16 A. The total load current of household appliances that are plugged into the sockets in this room is 30 A.

    In order to ensure reliable protection of all structural elements of the wiring, we select a circuit breaker at the lowest rated current of all the listed elements, that is 16 A (rated current of sockets). Such a circuit breaker (16 A) protects against damage to all elements of the wiring, including the socket from damage due to overload, but at the same time you will not be able to switch on the network all the necessary household appliances. Having connected all the necessary electrical appliances to the network, this circuit breaker will turn off as a result of overload, since the load current of 30 A is much higher than the rated current of the circuit breaker.

    In this case, the only option is to install a circuit breaker with a rated current of 32 A. It will provide protection against short circuits of all elements of the wiring, and from overload only the line that goes from the distribution panel to the junction box. At the same time, in order to protect the sockets and the lines that go from the junction box against overload, it is necessary to ensure that no electrical appliances are included in each of the sockets, the total load of which exceeds the permissible nominal value - 16 A.

    An introductory circuit breaker, which is installed on the input in the apartment distribution panel, serves to reserve the circuit breakers installed on each of the wiring lines. That is, if, in the event of damage on one of the wiring lines, the circuit breaker that protects it does not turn off, the input circuit breaker should trip. In addition, the input circuit breaker serves to protect against damage to the input cable, which goes from the access switchboard (or meter) to the switchboard of your apartment, as well as the meter.

    As for the additional parameters of circuit breakers, for example, the class of the device, in this case, for an apartment wiring, a circuit breaker of any class is suitable. The class of the machine shows the frequency of operation of the electromagnetic release, in simple words the current at which the circuit breaker instantly trips. This parameter is taken into account in cases where there are large inrush currents, for example, inrush current of the motor. If a short circuit occurs in the wiring diagram, large currents flow, so the circuit breaker, regardless of class, will trip instantly in any case.

    It should also be noted that the ambient temperature affects the operation of the thermal release of the circuit breaker. If the temperature is very high, the circuit breaker will trip when the load current is less than the rated value. If the ambient temperature is small, then the response time of the thermal release of the circuit breaker increases accordingly. For each type of circuit breaker, there are corresponding graphs of the dependence of the trip currents of the thermal release on the ambient temperature.

    As for the residual current circuit breaker, when choosing it, they are guided by a parameter such as differential current. Differential current is the leakage current that causes fires and electric shock to humans.When choosing a protective shutdown device, first of all, it is necessary to provide maximum protection for a person from electric shock. Even the smallest currents have a negative effect on the human body. By choosing a residual current circuit breaker with a differential operating current of 10 mA, the maximum protection of a person against electric shock is ensured, as well as fire protection. But not in all cases it is possible to install an RCD with such a threshold, since there is a natural leakage of current in the wiring, as well as household appliances connected to the network. In this case, by choosing a residual current circuit breaker with a small tripping current, it may turn off falsely, especially if the wiring is old.

    Also, to reserve devices installed on the wiring lines, it is necessary to install an RCD at the input of the distribution panel.

    When choosing an RCD, in addition to the differential trip current, it is necessary to take into account the rated current for each of the wiring lines. For example, a circuit breaker with a rated current of 16 A is installed on one of the lines, respectively, an RCD is installed on this line, which has a rated current of at least 16 A.

     
    Comments:

    # 3 wrote: Sergei | [quote]

     
     

    As a rule, to protect the group power cable of the plug sockets, the rated current of the protection device is 16A, and the protection of the power cable of the luminaires is 6 (10A). Accordingly, the installed power of the lighting group, as a rule, should not exceed 2 kW (usually less than 1 kW), and the power group of the plug sockets and power equipment should not exceed 3 kW. Due to the fact that RCDs do not provide protection against overload and short circuit currents, it is used exclusively in combination with a circuit breaker (fuse).

    The circuit breaker and RCD are installed in series, while the rated current of the RCD must be one step higher - i.e. 20A when installed in series with the machine on 16A, 32A when installed with the machine on 25A. Thus, when overloaded in the network, before the thermal protection of the machine is activated, the RCD will not be overloaded with the current passing through it.

    PUE 7.1.76. It is recommended to use an RCD, which is a single unit with a circuit breaker that provides overcurrent protection.

     
    Comments:

    # 4 wrote: Andrew | [quote]

     
     

    I consider the installation of RCDs at the input (although it is recommended by the PUE, which I trust and rely on) is generally not reasonable. A fire from a short circuit in modern conditions (modern PVC cable insulation, modern millisecond operation of modern automatic machines in short circuit) is an otmaza for the Ministry of Emergency Situations, which always blame the electrician. Try to connect a 220V bulb to a 200W machine and connect them with twisted wires in a PVC insulation with a cross section of 0.35mm2. You will see how they begin to melt and immediately turn off during short circuit. An RCD at the input is an extra reason to call an electrician to find the reason for the trip. The whole house will be without light. RCD (at their price today) is better to put on each distribution branch.

     
    Comments:

    # 5 wrote: MaksimovM | [quote]

     
     

    AndrewIn addition to the fire function, the RCD at the input of the home wiring acts as a backup protective device in case of failure of the RCD at one of the outgoing lines. In this case, we are talking about the safety of people, and you can’t save on this. No matter how reliable the protective device would be, the probability of its failure cannot be ruled out.