Categories: Featured Articles » Electrician at home
Number of views: 238,573
Comments on the article: 14

Wiring methods: from twists to soldering

 


Wiring methods: from twists to solderingThe article describes the various methods of connecting wires when wiring.

The wiring device requires a reliable connection of wires. In the sixties and seventies of the twentieth century, during the construction of the "Khrushchev" houses, wiring, purely for economic reasons, was carried out by an aluminum wire.

All connections in this wiring were made by the method of twisting, which were isolated with black cloth tape, and could last ten or more years without requiring any maintenance or prevention. Of course, if the twisting was performed according to all the rules. Therefore, old electricians argue that there is simply no more reliable twist, no connection.

Partly they are right. In those days, there was no other way, and it was not required, because the apartments did not yet have such an abundance of electrical and electronic equipment as now. The power of the then refrigerators, washing machines, irons and electric kettles was much lower than modern ones. And not all of them had refrigerators, televisions and washing machines.

And electricity consumers like air conditioners, computers, home theaters in apartments were not used at all. Then they just have not yet been invented. Therefore, it was possible to perform wiring with aluminum wires, and wire connection using twists.


Modern Wiring Requirements

In modern conditions, wiring is most often performed by copper wires, which allows you to connect the load of almost any power. Various methods are now used to connect the wires. This is stipulated in the rules of electrical installations (PUE). Literally they say: quote.


PUE: p2.1.21. Connection, branching and termination of conductors of wires and cables should be carried out by crimping, welding, soldering or clamping (screw, bolt, etc.) in accordance with applicable instructions.

From this paragraph of the rules it follows that it is impossible to connect wires with twist, it simply does not exist in the indicated paragraph. If the fire inspector will accept the wiring, then he simply will not accept the wiring made by the twist method, and it will have to be redone. Twisting is permissible only as a temporary joint before welding, which will be discussed in the next article.


Connection of wires with clamps

According to the specified item of the PUE, for connecting wires currently exist terminal blockswhich should be used. The most common are three types of terminal blocks. These are self-locking, screw and connecting insulating clamps. Figure 1 shows a self-clamping terminal block.

Self-locking terminal block

Figure 1. Self-locking terminal block


Self-locking terminal blocks designed to connect wires with a cross section of up to 2.5 mm2, their operating current reaches 24A, which allows you to connect a load of up to 5KW. The number of places in such terminal blocks is from 2 to 8, which greatly speeds up the installation of wiring as a whole. True, in comparison with twisting, they occupy more space in the junction boxes, which is not always convenient.

The design of the screw terminal blocks is shown in Figure 2.

Screw terminal block

Figure 2. Screw terminal block

This type of terminal block is the most common and therefore is used more often than other types. The main area of ​​their application is the connection of wires in junction boxes. However, if the wiring is carried out with an aluminum wire, you should refrain from using such terminal blocks, since when tightening the screws it is possible to pinch and break off the soft aluminum wire.

The third type of mechanical wire connectors is connecting insulating clamps (PPE). Their appearance is shown in Figure 3.

PPE clamps

Figure 3. PPE clamps

Such a clamp is a plastic case, inside of which there is an anodized conical spring. To connect the wires, they are stripped to a length of about 10 - 15 mm and stacked in a common bundle. After which PPE is wound on it, turning clockwise until it stops. With their help, it is possible to connect several single wires with a total area of ​​2.5 - 20 mm2. Naturally, the caps in these cases are of different sizes.

Such clamps accelerate installation, and due to the insulated housing do not require additional insulation. True, the connection quality is slightly lower than that of screw terminal blocks. Therefore, ceteris paribus, preference should still be given to the latter.


Solder connection

The connection of wires by soldering and welding is most reliable than using terminal connectors of various designs. Copper wires are best soldered, and although there are currently various fluxes for brazing aluminum, it is better to refrain from such soldering.

Compared to welding soldering is simpler and more affordable: it does not require expensive equipment, less fire hazard, the skills to perform good quality soldering will require more modest than when performing a welded joint.

If you solder the twists from time to time, for example, you decide change wiring in your apartment, it’s quite possible to get along conventional soldering iron power not less than 100 watts. When the brazing of the strands is to be done almost every day, as regards your main or additional work, it is better to use the same 100-watt soldering iron after finalizing its tip, as indicated in Figure 4.

Refinement soldering iron tip

Figure 4. Refinement of the soldering iron tip

For such refinement, the soldering iron tip should be pulled out of the soldering iron body and grinded off with a file or cut off its working wedge-shaped part with a hacksaw. After this operation, drill a hole with a diameter of 6 - 7 mm to a depth of 30 - 40 mm in a copper sting.

Although special precision during drilling is not required in this case, if possible, it is better to cut the end and drill a hole on the lathe.

After installing the tip back into the soldering iron, the hole must be tin-plated from the inside, in the same way as for a simple soldering iron. Thus, a small-sized tin bath is obtained.

Before soldering, of course, the insulation is first removed from each wire to a length of 40..50 mm, and each individual wire is stripped to a metallic luster, and then tin-coated.

To do this, a small amount of solder should be melted in the hole of the soldering rod, then add a little rosin and immerse the wire in the hole. If there is any liquid flux, for example, a solution of rosin in alcohol, then simply lubricate the wire with liquid flux and dip the wire into the molten solder.

Then carefully twist the tinned wires, cut the ends at the same level and, taking them with pliers, dip them into the solder bath.

In such a device, it is possible to solder a twist of 4-6 cores with a cross section of up to 2.5 mm2. In this case, twisting should be held for about 3-4 seconds in order to completely warm up. The soldering should cool in air and have a brilliant contour appearance.

When using pine rosin as a flux, the soldered joint does not need to be washed. If other fluxes are used, proceed according to the instructions attached to them.

It is completely unacceptable to accelerate the process by cooling the solder with water: this leads to the formation of microcracks and, of course, to a deterioration in the quality of the joint.

Twist insulation is best done with shrink tubecorresponding diameter, warming it with a technical hairdryer. In the absence of a tube, you can use ordinary electrical tape by wrapping it in at least three layers.

See also: Welding wire connection

Boris Aladyshkin

See also at bgv.electricianexp.com:

  • Why welding is always better than other wire connection methods
  • Why wire twisting is prohibited
  • Connection by welding aluminum wires
  • How to connect wires correctly
  • Which wire connection is more reliable - Wago clamps or twisting? The story is real ...

  •  
     
    Comments:

    # 1 wrote: | [quote]

     
     
    Comments:

    # 2 wrote: Vasiliy | [quote]

     
     

    I agree with Alexei, only twisting and then welding it. PPEs are good, but also for twisting. In this case, the twist should be no less than 40-60 mm, since the current flows along the contact area, the PPE fixes the wires and does not allow compression to weaken with time. And then it is necessary to completely insulate the contact to ensure the tightness of the connection. With a simple connection side by side and compression, the connection can oxidize and the contact fails. The use of self-clamping terminal blocks of the "VAGA" type, only for lighting circuits up to 3 kW, well, they do not hold more, after six months or a year, they melt if the wet room is oxidized and again begins to burn. Well, as for the screw terminal blocks - this is reliable, but on condition that there are no "Chinese" terminal blocks that burst when tightened, and again the connection area, connected in a joint of 2.5 mm square. such a terminal block does not stretch 5 kW, for a long time - they will burn out. Constantly have to redo these grief "new technology", and usually after the end of warranty service, that is, somewhere in a year and a half.

     
    Comments:

    # 3 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    when welding, the metal structure is violated and in the place of welding, and next to it, twisting under the standard load starts to fade

     
    Comments:

    # 4 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    We changed the wiring at old facilities in connection with an increase in power consumption, 20-30 years ago, all connections are welding + CB tape. The wiring is in normal condition, the welded joints are not affected in any way, this is an ideal connection, compared to terminals or wagons for example. I not only advertise our device, but also from my own experience and the stranger say it as it is. Welding is also cheaper than anything else; the electrode lasts for half a year of average work.

    Do not forget that the goal of manufacturers of various connectors also includes the task of constant marketing, i.e. they are not interested in their products serving forever ...

     
    Comments:

    # 5 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    I agree with Alex. Welding is the simplest, cheapest, and fastest !!!

    For example, I cook with the simplest carbon brush electrode and transformer, and an excellent connection ....

    And this whole advertisement of fashionable terminal blocks with space prices is necessary .... away)))))))))))

     
    Comments:

    # 6 wrote: Pavel S. | [quote]

     
     

    For aluminum conductor wires and cables, there is another good way to connect - termite welding. It is especially convenient to use thermite welding for connecting steel strips and rods in grounding networks. True, this method of connection requires a serious attitude in terms of safety, especially termite cartridges. Just when they burn, then they have a temperature of about 2000 degrees, and even with cooling fragments of termite cartridges can be seriously burned. But, with regard to the quality of the electrical contact obtained, there is simply no equal to thermite welding.

     
    Comments:

    # 7 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    According to GOST R 50571.15-97 it is not recommended to use soldering when connecting the conductors of power circuits.

     
    Comments:

    # 8 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    I use a conventional welding machine to connect the wires. First, I twist, and then the ends are scalded with a carbon rod from the battery.

     
    Comments:

    # 9 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    It would be better to dwell on the terminals of the company WAGO.

     
    Comments:

    # 10 wrote: Konstantin | [quote]

     
     

    The rules for the installation of electrical installations (PUE) contain the following mandatory requirements for connecting wires: all connections should be easily accessible for inspection, all types of connections should be made only in junction boxes, connections in pipes are strictly prohibited (boxes must be closed with lids).

     
    Comments:

    # 11 wrote: | [quote]

     
     

    From my own experience I know that there is nothing better than welding. Now, after I got welding appatat - I only weld. Previously, I soldered copper wires, tried soldering irons of various capacities, but they didn’t work for me, so I soldered them using a gas burner. First, he moistened the twist with an alcohol solution of rosin, then he brought the flame of the burner to the twist, and after 5-7 seconds, when the alcohol burned out, extinguished the twist, brought the solder to the twist and slightly heated with the burner, it was soldered. In time, the soldering of the twist took no more than 12 - 15 seconds. As for the terminal blocks, they have very limited use. That is, they are limited by very small, at present, currents (up to 5A). In this case, under no circumstances should a butt joint be used on screw terminal blocks, but only an overlap, i.e. counter wires must be passed under both screws and then tightened. If the circumstances are such that there is no welding machine at hand, and you need to connect aluminum wires through which it is supposed to pass large currents (up to 40A), then after stripping the wires you need to make a tight twist, and then put this twist into the appropriate size terminal block and clamp two screws. Or even apply a bolted connection when two neat loops of wires are put on a bolt between two washers, and then tightly clamped with a nut.
    Especially it is necessary to say about the case when you have to connect copper and aluminum wires. If you, having come to the client, found a burning twist in which half of the wires are copper and half are aluminum, then after stripping the wires, separate them: collect the copper separately, adding one more free end to the twist, and the aluminum - exactly the same separately . Then connect the two free ends with a bolted connection, laying a brass washer between them (in no case an iron washer!)

     
    Comments:

    # 12 wrote: Vania | [quote]

     
     

    Quote: Alex
    Do not forget that the goal of manufacturers of various connectors also includes the task of constant marketing, i.e. they are not interested in their products serving forever ...

    You might think that you have other goals.

     
    Comments:

    # 13 wrote: MaksimovM | [quote]

     
     

    At the expense of the fact that connector manufacturers are not interested in the reliability of their products - I do not agree. People choose those terminals that have proven themselves well, that is, those products that meet their nominal characteristics and last for a long time. The same can be said of the welding machine. If the welding machine quickly fails, then the person from this manufacturer will no longer purchase products, and will not recommend this company to other people.

     
    Comments:

    # 14 wrote: vitaly | [quote]

     
     

    If you need to connect aluminum wires or aluminum and copper wires, it is better to use a bolted connection with washers between each wire. Copper must be tinned. The bolt and washers must be galvanized. You must also use a spring washer. No brass and copper washers. See permissible metal contact pairs. I myself saw how the combination of brass and aluminum burns.